Why a robot may be a fairer judge than a human

Larry Bellehumeur, M2M / IoT Consultant,
Novotech Technologies

Late last year, I had the pleasure of being called for jury duty. During the proceedings, where the defendant was accused of armed robbery among other offences, the judge mentioned that there were actually two trials going on. For this one, a jury was being selected, but for the other one, the defendant opted for a judge-only trial.

That got me thinking…if I was ever charged with a major crime where I had the choice, which one would I pick? Would you opt for a trial where you are judged by your peers, whom may be more sympathetic or by a judge, who is supposed to be more partial? How about a third option – a robot? said Larry Bellehumeur, M2M/IoT Consultant at Novotech Technologies.

What brought this up was a recent study in Israel that examined the success rate of parole applications. What they found was staggering….

On average, about 35% of all parole applications are approved. However, in the two hours proceeding lunch, the success rate fell, dipping close to zero for the case that was heard right before lunch. After lunch, the rates spiked to 65% before declining back to the norm about an hour later. So, your chance of getting parole may have had more to do with the judge’s blood sugar level than the merits of your case, or so it seems…

Ok, but it must be that a skilled judge is better than a piece of machinery at determining a lot of things including the chances of a criminal repeating their bad behaviour, right? Sorry to disappoint, but study after study has shown that software programs which incorporate wide varieties of data are far superior to judges and juries when it comes to determining recidivism.

Today’s software programs are also far superior to all but the best legal researchers when it comes to determining precedents that most affect a particular case or set of facts.

“All rise, Robbie the Robot?”

The reality is that this is not likely to happen anytime soon. However, it does make sense that these tools can be used to determine some facts that better allow today’s judicial system to make informed decisions, and at a much faster pace. This would also help clear up some of the backlog that most jurisdictions are seeing in their court systems.

The bottom line

If the world of Big Data / AI can play a role in the legal system, is there any area that is truly safe? At this point, maybe not, but that is not always a bad thing. In many cases, it makes sense to have things be truly impartial, such as in a legal proceeding, and perhaps having a different set of “eyes” look over the facts may make us a better society…as long as the robots do not have to wear the judges’ wigs, as I may not be able to get out of jury duty if I am laughing at the fact that my judge looks like the maid from the Jetsons!

The author of this blog is Larry Bellehumeur, M2M / IoT Consultant, Novotech Technologies

Comment on this article below or via Twitter: @IoTNow_ OR @jcIoTnow


9 IoT applications that will change everything

Posted on: September 1, 2021

Whether you are a future-minded CEO, tech-driven CEO or IT leader, you’ve come across the term IoT before. It’s often used alongside superlatives regarding how it will revolutionize the way you work, play, and live. But is it just another buzzword, or is it the as-promised technological holy grail? The truth is that Internet of

Read more

Which IoT Platform 2021? IoT Now Enterprise Buyers’ Guide

Posted on: August 30, 2021

There are several different parts in a complete IoT solution, all of which must work together to get the result needed, write IoT Now Enterprise Buyers’ Guide – Which IoT Platform 2021? authors Robin Duke-Woolley, the CEO and Bill Ingle, a senior analyst, at Beecham Research. Figure 1 shows these parts and, although not all

Read more

CAT-M1 vs NB-IoT – examining the real differences

Posted on: June 21, 2021

As industry players look to provide the next generation of IoT connectivity, two different standards have emerged under release 13 of 3GPP – CAT-M1 and NB-IoT.

Read more

IoT and home automation: What does the future hold?

Posted on: June 10, 2020

Once a dream, iot home automation is slowly but steadily becoming a part of daily lives around the world. In fact, it is believed that the global market for smart home automation will reach $40 billion by 2020.

Read more

World Economic Forum launches toolbox of solutions to accelerate decarbonisation in cities

Posted on: September 23, 2021

With the percentage of people living in cities projected to rise to 68% by 2050, resulting in high energy consumption, greater infrastructure needs and, carbon emissions, cities have a critical role to play in the race to reach net zero. To help address this challenge, the World Economic Forum, is releasing iteration of its Toolbox of Solutions,

Read more

Laserfiche announces launch of cloud document management and process automation solution

Posted on: September 23, 2021

Laserfiche announced the availability of Laserfiche Cloud in the Europe, Middle East and Africa (EMEA) region. The SaaS provider of intelligent content management and business process automation’s cloud offering delivers an innovative and trusted system for securely managing content and automating business processes across the enterprise.

Read more