Killed off by NTT DoCoMo: NB-IoT still kicking globally, but for how long?

Nadja Kirchof

Japan’s telco, NTT DoCoMo, shut down its NarrowBand-IoT (NB-IoT) network on March 31st. Coming barely a year after NTT’s services were launched,  Jeremy Cowan editorial director of IoT Now turned to industry watchers for their views on the decision and what lies ahead for NB-IoT.

Asked on the recent inaugural Tech Trends Podcast (download free here) what lay behind NTT’s decision, George Malim, IoT Now’s managing editor says, “I guess there’s a lot of contributing factors. One is the fragmentation in the low power wide area connectivity market. There’s Sigfox, there’s LoRa, there’s still 2G, it depends on what market you are in, and I think that confusion is one element.

Another element is the volumes just haven’t arrived we’re looking at very thin margins. Some providers are offering you down to maybe a euro or dollar a year for the SIM cards in this space over a long period and that means you’ve got to have billions of connections and without billions of connections the technology possibly doesn’t stand up.

“I think the third thing in the room is 5G. Telecoms providers are basically focusing nearly all of their investment on 5G. NTT itself announced at the end of last year it’s going to retire its i-mode service. Now, that’s pretty much Japan-specific, but it did have tens of millions of subscribers, and it probably still does.

I think it peaked about 10 years ago with close to 50 million subscribers. So, it’s just a basic mobile data service. But for NTT to say they’re going to give up on i-mode is symptomatic of putting all their eggs in the 5G basket. It’s either that or they just don’t like hyphens in their technologies,” he joked.

Malim points out that the economies of scale only come when the market comprises tens of billions of connected Things. Building a dedicated network like NB-IoT for a smaller market does not give the expected savings. In these circumstances, Malim maintains, NB-IoT probably doesn’t look much cheaper than modelling done around LTE-M, for example. The same pattern is not necessarily true in other markets outside Japan. Vodafone is heavily committed to NB-IoT and so are others.

As he reports, in the past month several European operators have signed their first Narrowband IoT roaming agreements. The co-operation will cover Deutsche Telekom, Swisscom, Telia Company and Vodafone bringing mobile IoT roaming services to a further nine European countries on top of DT’s NB-IoT roaming in nine of its own markets. The roaming agreements are a response to customer demand for international coverage and service continuity for the growing number of IoT devices.

DT’s corporate spokeswoman, Nadja Kirchof states, “Only managed mobile services on licensed spectrum provide the network interoperability and secure IoT connections needed to meet future demand. Additional NB-IoT roaming agreements with further operator partners are expected in the coming months.

In the same podcast, Matt Hatton, co-founder of analysts Transforma Insights comments, “I think the essential challenge is that there hasn’t been a de facto standard for… the low power wide area (LPWA) space.

It’s pretty fragmented compared to the likes of the personal area network which is all Bluetooth or the local area network, which is predominantly WiFi with a bit of 802.15.4 thrown in for your industrial applications. You’ve got NB-IoT, which is really the only candidate for nationwide, wide area connectivity for that narrowband deployment. But it’s had its teething problems. Those quick and cheap upgrades really weren’t, and the battery life hasn’t quite been what’s been hoped.”

NB-IoT, the problem child

Robin Duke-Woolley

“NB-IoT has been a problem child for some time,” according to Robin Duke-Woolley, CEO and founder of UK-based Beecham Research. “It is way behind Cat M1/LTE-M in implementation and is not currently achieving the benefits in particular, the power savings hoped for. Unlike CatM1, NB-IoT is not designed for roaming and that is OK for a technology that is aimed at static applications.

“However, NB-IoT implementations in different networks and different countries do not currently interwork so when the product is manufactured you need to know in which country it will end up. Further than that, there may not be interworking even between NB-IoT networks in the same country, so if you have an NB-IoT device on Network A in a country, you might not be able to move it to Network B in the same country.

In other words, if you choose NB-IoT, you may end up being locked in to one operator indefinitely. This is an issue that has been the subject of much discussion and head-scratching at 3GPP to overcome and, as far as I know, that work is continuing but remains a problem for now.”

“In contrast, CatM1 has never provided implementation issues. It works well,” adds Duke-Woolley, “is very reliable, and can be implemented on any network that runs CatM1. It is not quite as low-cost and power-saving as NB-IoT is aiming to be.

My reading is that NTT has decided to put its narrowband cellular efforts behind CatM1 for this reason. It is also worth noting that NTT has been working on LoRa for several years and is a member of the LoRa Alliance. It may well now use LoRa / LoRaWAN as its lower cost narrowband alternative to CatM1 in the same way that Orange in France, for example, is already doing.”

Pricing is not too low

Samuel Hale

IoT needs to see prices at that level to connect everything everywhere, but to do that needs a lot of standardisation and automation. If NB-IoT cannot provide that, then other technologies will be pushed more heavily to provide that.”

For a US perspective, I turned to Samuel Hale, analyst and IoT implementation specialist at MachNation. Why does he think NTT has terminated its Narrowband IoT services? Hale replies, “NB-IoT is a volume game. Unless a carrier has huge volume or expects it within a reasonable timeframe it’s very expensive to add all the hardware needed on the network side to support NB-IoT. At full scale, NB-IoT is arguably cheaper than LTE Cat M1 to support deployments like smart metering. But if a carrier doesn’t believe that these smart metering-type solutions are going to be pervasive enough, then making the case to support NB-IoT fades.”

What’s the impact outside Japan?

So, will NTT’s decision affect NB-IoT use outside Japan? If so, what will the impact be and where?

Hale suggests that, “NTT withdrawing from NB-IoT isn’t the straw that broke the camel’s back. NTT’s decision to drop NB-IoT will not impact China’s decision to stick with NB-IoT in the near term. China likes NB-IoT for reasons unrelated to technology. However, in the longer term it is likely that Europe will drop NB-IoT. And we already know that North America is more likely to adopt LTE-based solutions than NB-IoT.”

The last word on possible consequences outside Japan of NTT’s decision goes to Duke-Woolley. Yes, he believes it may have a wider impact, “although there is currently heavy commitment to NB-IoT in many countries. It is really a question of whether NB-IoT can deliver the low cost, power saving and other benefits that it has been expected to do and if so when.

The tide may be turning against NB-IoT as the main way forward for low-cost connectivity for the wider Internet of Things.It is not yet too late for this to be turned around but the issues with NB-IoT need to be addressed if they are to be and it is getting late in the day.”

Jeremy Cowan

The author, Jeremy Cowan, is editorial director of IoT Now, VanillaPlus and The Evolving Enterprise.

Comment on this article below or via Twitter: @IoTNow_OR @jcIoTnow


T-Mobile launches advanced industry solutions

Posted on: October 3, 2022

Bellevue, United States – T-Mobile unveiled advanced industry solutions, an end-to-end suite of connectivity, compute, devices, and applications needed to make smart cities, autonomous factories, and more, possible. Businesses and municipalities no longer have to wade through endless options of technology vendors because the un-carrier is bringing it all together.

Read more

Fibocom Launches New Generation of 5G Sub-6GHz and mmWave Module FX170(W) Series Based on Snapdragon X65 5G Modem-RF System at MWC Las Vegas 2022

Posted on: October 3, 2022

(Sponsored News) During MWC Las Vegas 2022, Fibocom launches 5G Sub-6GHz and mmWave module FX170(W) series based on Snapdragon® X65 5G Modem-RF System, delivering enhanced broadband capabilities with superior performance.

Read more

9 IoT applications that will change everything

Posted on: September 1, 2021

Whether you are a future-minded CEO, tech-driven CEO or IT leader, you’ve come across the term IoT before. It’s often used alongside superlatives regarding how it will revolutionize the way you work, play, and live. But is it just another buzzword, or is it the as-promised technological holy grail? The truth is that Internet of

Read more

Which IoT Platform 2021? IoT Now Enterprise Buyers’ Guide

Posted on: August 30, 2021

There are several different parts in a complete IoT solution, all of which must work together to get the result needed, write IoT Now Enterprise Buyers’ Guide – Which IoT Platform 2021? authors Robin Duke-Woolley, the CEO and Bill Ingle, a senior analyst, at Beecham Research. Figure 1 shows these parts and, although not all

Read more

CAT-M1 vs NB-IoT – examining the real differences

Posted on: June 21, 2021

As industry players look to provide the next generation of IoT connectivity, two different standards have emerged under release 13 of 3GPP – CAT-M1 and NB-IoT.

Read more

IoT and home automation: What does the future hold?

Posted on: June 10, 2020

Once a dream, home automation using iot is slowly but steadily becoming a part of daily lives around the world. In fact, it is believed that the global market for smart home automation will reach $40 billion by 2020.

Read more

5 challenges still facing the Internet of Things

Posted on: June 3, 2020

The Internet of Things (IoT) has quickly become a huge part of how people live, communicate and do business. All around the world, web-enabled devices are turning our world into a more switched-on place to live.

Read more

What is IoT?

Posted on: July 7, 2019

What is IoT Data as a new oil IoT connectivity What is IoT video So what’s IoT? The phrase ‘Internet of Things’ (IoT) is officially everywhere. It constantly shows up in my Google news feed, the weekend tech supplements are waxing lyrical about it and the volume of marketing emails I receive advertising ‘smart, connected

Read more
IoT Newsletter

Join the IoT Now online community for FREE, to receive: Exclusive offers for entry to all the IoT events that matter, round the world

Free access to a huge selection of the latest IoT analyst reports and industry whitepapers

The latest IoT news, as it breaks, to your inbox