Latest Mercedes-Benz autonomous driving assistant falls short of expectations, finds Strategy Analytics

Derek Viita

A recent user experience evaluation from the In-vehicle UX (IVX) group at Strategy Analytics has assessed Mercedes-Benz’s Semi-Autonomous Driving Assistant in a 2018 S-Class Sedan. On completion, Strategy Analytics found that this iteration shows improvements in control location, but repeats issues with small visual icons and a lack of audible or tactile feedback, leading to moderate IVX scores for usability. System-initiated emergency stops during escalated takeover warnings also have troubling safety implications.

Click here for report.

Key report findings include:

  • In a notable positive design change, primary ACC controls are now located on the steering wheel rather than buried on a stalk control.
  • Visual assets are entirely co-located at the bottom of the instrument cluster, and one notable icon is slightly larger.

However, several critical human factors issues remain:

  • Proper function requires that steering assist and lane-keeping modes remain active. Hiding these controls on a console behind the steering wheel is not conducive to discovery or usability of either.
  • No audible or tactile feedback is provided when an operator hands off to the vehicle, or during initial takeover warnings.
Chris Schreiner

Derek Viita, report author and senior analyst commented, “Because a lack of consumer trust is one of the biggest roadblocks to a fully autonomous ecosystem, automakers such as Daimler have an enviable position. Semi-autonomous features such as Mercedes Benz’s advanced driving assistants could serve as a ’gateway’ to showcase Daimler’s ability to create safe and enjoyable assisted-driving (or non-driving) experiences.

However, it is currently a wasted opportunity due to a poor holistic understanding of the semi-autonomous use case, particularly with respect to human-machine interface (HMI) design.”

Added Chris Schreiner, director, Syndicated Research UXIP: “As interest in autonomous driving features has returned to an upward trend, the next few model years and semi-autonomous iterations will be critical in determining whether automakers are truly gaining consumer trust.”

Comment on this article below or via Twitter: @IoTNow_OR @jcIoTnow

Recent Articles

Improving the reliability of the Internet of Things

Posted on: December 3, 2020

Over-the-air updates are enabling a dramatic change in the way systems in the Internet of Things (IoT) operate. Here, Johan Kraft, CEO and founder of Percepio explains the benefits.

Read more

Inaugural IoT online conference launches backed by Percepio

Posted on: December 3, 2020

Embedded software tool provider Percepio is helping engineers navigate challenges on the Internet of Things (IoT) by sponsoring a new conference and virtual exhibition. Organised by embedded industry experts Stephane Boucher of Embedded Related and Jacob Beningo of the Beningo Embedded Group, the IoT Online Conference brings together experts from industry and academia December 8-9th in an all-digital event.

Read more